Final thoughts: I'm about 90% happy with it. There are a couple small flaws that aren't huge (especially considering what I paid) but I know they are there and if I tell you there are flaws, you could probably find them. I'm going to order some Plasti-Dip and the "Glossifier" and re-do the inserts so they aren't so flat against the gloss black.
Hopefully he'll be doing my tailgate next month some time.